CLINICAL SUPERVISOR GRADING


 

General Policies

Although specific methods of evaluation remain within the jurisdiction of each department or program, certain general policies regarding evaluation have been approved as mandatory.

  1. Evaluation must be on-going and this evaluation must be discussed with the clerk at least midway through the rotation (for rotations of 6 weeks or longer) and at the end of the rotation. Evaluation discussions with the clerk should focus on the clerk's contribution to and performance in the clerkship, and can be guided by the performance criteria listed on the assessment form.
  2. It is strongly recommended that all student evaluations be signed by the student prior to the evaluation being forwarded to the Dean's Office, Vancouver General Hospital (VGH). It is mandatory that a 'Does Not Meet Requirements' or 'Requires Improvement' assessment, or one containing unfavourable comments in the narrative portion of the evaluation, be signed by the student prior to this evaluation being forwarded to the Dean's Office, VGH. Any such evaluations received by the Dean's Office, VGH without the student's signature will be returned to the department.
  3. Although a resident may sign an evaluation, it cannot be the only signature appearing on the evaluation.
  4. All clerks have access to completed evaluations through the Dean's Office, VGH. If the clerk does not feel a fair evaluation has been submitted, they must address any concerns with the course director before presenting them to the Associate Dean, Student Affairs. See the "Appeals Policy' included later in this document for a more detailed outline of this process.

 

Daily formative assessments

Daily assessment discussions should be intrinsic to clerks' clinical experiences. There should be some general discussion about how each clerk is functioning. This daily assessment focuses on self-assessment skills, which are an important part of the clinical encounter process and central to the concept of educating medical clerks to become self-critical clinicians. The supervisor or preceptor should also spend a few minutes discussing particular issues with individual clerks after a patient encounter. If necessary, it should also be possible for the clerk to book time to meet with the supervisor.

Modeling of assessment skills by the supervisors and preceptors (i.e., the supervisor providing feedback to clerks) is an important way for clerks to develop self-assessment skills.

 

Mid-rotation self- and supervisor assessments

At the mid-point of each clerkship with a duration of 6 or more weeks, clerks will be asked to prepare a written self-assessment of their personal progress in each of the identified areas (see Skill Areas section later in this document), and their plans for addressing any self-perceived weaknesses in the remainder of the clerkship. The self-assessment will be recorded on the form: Clerk Mid-Rotation Self-Assessment. This mid-rotation self-assessment will be discussed with the clinical supervisor at the middle of each rotation. The clerk retains the completed self-assessment form for inclusion in their Assessment Portfolio. Preparing this assessment is not expected to be an arduous task and its purpose is largely formative. A clerk's self-assessment will help the supervisor provide the clerk with feedback regarding the clerk's progress. Besides giving supervisors insight into the clerk's self-assessment skills, it should help identify clerks who may be having difficulties. A principal role of the self-assessment process is to form a 'learning contract' for the remainder of the clerkship.

A mid-rotation discussion with each clerk and their supervisor will be held to review both the clerk's self-assessment as well as supervisor's feedback based on direct observation and/or preceptors' reports of a clerk's progress.

 

End-of-Clerkship Summative Assessments and Grading

Supervisors will attempt to provide a formal summative assessment of each clerk on an End-of-Clerkship Clinical Clerk Evaluation form at the end of the clerkship. For this final evaluation, the supervisor will assign clerks one rating across all the skill areas that have been identified. The supervisor will include a detailed narrative assessment intended to identify the clerks' strengths, areas for which improvement is needed, and recommendations to guide improvement (see appended form). At the conclusion of the clerkship, supervisors should provide clerks and the Dean's Office with a copy of the completed assessment form. The supervisor assessment of clerks should, as much as possible, be based on a clerk's degree of mastery of skills, rather than on comparisons of one clerk with another.

Each marking category will receive only on equivalent percentage grade. It is recommended that no other percentages are to be used to grade clinical performance. The percentage grade that is appropriate to each marking category is indicated below:

The supervisor's grades will be based on health care team ratings and comments regarding each clerk's performance in the identified skill areas (see following section). It is recommended that, when arriving at an overall mark for the clerkship, the supervisor grade will be weighted equally with other clerkship grading components.

To help supervisors provide useful and accurate assessments, and to work toward consistent grading practices across supervisors, the following guidelines should be followed:

  1. As a baseline position, the majority of clerks should be judged to have 'met requirements' -- this is considered a highly positive assessment.
  2. On occasion, a few clerks will stand out as having difficulty and will be judged as 'requires improvement' or 'does not meet requirements'. It is important to substantiate judgements of 'requires improvement' or 'does not meet requirements' with narrative comments identifying the areas of concern. The rating category 'requires improvement' is still a pass, but is very useful for alerting the clerk, the clerk's academic advisor and the Dean's office that the supervisor feels the clerk is in potential difficulty and in need of additional help. If a supervisor has concerns about a clerk, these should be addressed to the clerk well before the final assessment.
  3. It is also important to substantiate judgments of exceeds requirements with narrative coments that justify this high rating. A few clerks (most often 2-4 of 18-20 in a clerkship) will stand out as exceptional and will be judged to have exceeded requirements.
  4. The narrative comments recorded on the clerks' performance should follow the guidelines for providing useful feedback (see Assessment Skills criteria on back of assessment form) -- e.g., they should be descriptive (not judgmental), specific, balanced (strengths and weaknesses), and limited (two or three main issues only).

 

Ward Remediation

Clerks who require improvement based on their overall clinical performance rating may be required to utilize a Phase V elective for remediating ward performance. A CIP (currently in progress) grade will appear on the transcript until a remedial elective is successfully completed. At least a 'meets requirements' rating must be achieved in the Phase V remediation elective. If at least a 'meets requirements' is not achieved, a failing mark will be entered on the clerk's transcript and the Student Promotions Committee, Years 3 & 4 will meet to determine qualification for a supplemental program (see below), repetition of Phase IV, or withdrawal from the program. Any remediation program scheduled for Phase V must be immediately reported to the Student Promotions Committee, Years 3 & 4 through the Associate Dean, Undergraduate Program. Due to the limited elective blocks in Phase V, only one or two Phase IV clerkships will be able to prescribe ward remediation electives in Phase V.

 

Forward Feeding

The purpose of forward feeding is to enhance clerk performance. Clerkship directors who believe that information concerning a clerk should be passed on to subsequent clerkships will inform the Dean's Office in writing. The Associate Dean, Student Affairs will review the information, and, if forward feeding is required, meet with the clerk to discuss the process and the information that will be shared. It is the responsibility of the Associate Dean, Student Affairs to notify the clerkship director who has recommended forward feeding of any consequent actions that have (or have not) been taken regarding the clerk.

 

Follow-up Activities

The end of clerkship supervisor assessment of clerks will be kept by the Dean's Office for the duration of a clerk's tenure in the program so that they can be accessed as required by Promotions, Appeals and other Committees. Final grades along with narrative comments are sent to the Dean's Office for each clerk who completes all the clerkship requirements. Grades are based on the sum of weighted scores derived from assessments of clinical performance (including oral and written case presentations), written examinations, and oral examinations.

In the event of a 'does not meet requirements' rating in a clerk's clinical performance, the clerkship director must submit a letter to the Associate Dean, Student Affairs, summarizing the reason for the failing grade and recommendations for a supplemental program.

A clerk with a 'does not meet requirements' or 'requires improvement' rating on the clinical supervisor's final evaluation must meet with their academic advisor as well as the Associate Dean, Student Affairs, to plan for additional assistance in the area(s) of weakness.

 

Criteria for Assessing the Performance of Clerks in Clinical Settings

Clinical Supervisors will assess and provide clerks with feedback in each of the following areas. The statements are included in the back of the Assessment Form and are intended to describe the types of behaviours that clerks are expected to demonstrate during their clinical experiences. The items in the lists below should be considered examples, as complex behaviours cannot be reduced to a comprehensive list of component behaviours.

 

Clinical Skills

Takes an appropriate history and/or conduct an appropriate interview

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to acquire from the patient, family, or other sources a chronological, medically logical description of pertinent events. The clerk must acquire the information in sufficient breadth and depth to permit a clear definition of the patient’s problem upon which to base further investigation, diagnosis and management.

Performs an appropriate physical examination

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to elicit physical findings that document the presence or absence of abnormalities relevant to the patient’s problem. In doing so, the clerk will demonstrate a caring and supportive attitude with regard to the physical and emotional comfort of the patient.

Appropriately recognizes patient problems and generates differential diagnosis

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to identify important information and reach a reasonable diagnosis based on sound basic and clinical knowledge. Decisions should be made in a timely fashion to establish a program of investigation and management adapted to the patient’s condition, recognizing the limits of his/her own ability, the hazards of the therapy, and the need to modify therapy when indicated.

Appropriately orders and interprets diagnostic tests

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to order appropriate laboratory or other diagnostic procedures that elucidate or confirm the diagnosis and an awareness of the cost of these investigations, as well as be sensitive to any inconvenience, discomfort, or harm to the patient inherent in them.

Formulates and implements appropriate treatment and follow-up plan

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to make decisions in a timely fashion to establish a program of investigation and management adapted to the patient’s condition, recognizing the limits of his/her own ability, the hazards of the therapy and the need to modify therapy when indicated.

Written records are accurate, complete, well organized, up-to-date, and legible.

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to maintain records that accurately reflect the pertinent clinical data, investigation and treatment. These records should be of sufficient clarity, organization and detail to permit present and future interpretation of the record by him/herself and others. The clerk will complete records and reports promptly in order to ensure adequate patient care and follow-up and continuing care.

Presents cases in a concise, logical, accurate and organized manner

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to organize data in a logical manner and to integrate the data that defines the problem. The clerk must also discuss the rationale for the arriving at the diagnosis and laboratory investigation(s) selected, and be able to demonstrate an understanding of their physiological, biochemical and pathological basis and discuss their reliability and predictability.

 

Professional Behaviours

Reliable work habits with responsibility toward pts & staff, punctuality & attendance

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to accept and fulfill his/her responsibility to both patients and colleagues. The clerk will respond to patient needs in a timely and thoughtful manner and will arrange for the care of his/her patients during absence. The clerk will demonstrate willingness to seek the advice of supervisors when the diagnosis or management of the patient is in doubt. Honesty, integrity, conscientiousness and reliability will characterize his/her professional activities.

Initiative and motivation to learn

Clerks must actively participate in the educational opportunities available to them. The clerk will demonstrate the ability to maintain a program of self-directed learning based upon self-evaluation and the evaluation of teachers and peers. The clerk will participate in the teaching of others, when appropriate.

Communicates respectfully during patient and pt’s family interactions

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to communicate effectively with the patient and the family. The clerk will demonstrate a compassionate interest and overall understanding of the patient as a person. The clerk will demonstrate the ability to inspire confidence and obtain the cooperation of the patient and the family. The clerk must demonstrate attention to preventive measures by incorporating into his/her plan of management strategies to assist the patient in maintaining an optimal state of physical and mental health. The clerk must demonstrate the ability to instruct the patient and the patient’s family with regard to risk factors and modification of lifestyle based on current understanding in these matters.

Self-assessment skills: awareness of limitations of own knowledge & accepts criticism

The clerk must demonstrate an awareness of the limits of his/her capabilities and the ability to function adequately within the limits of his/her competence as determined by training and experience. The clerk must demonstrate the ability to assess his/her own progress realistically and to determine his/her learning needs with the assistance, when necessary, of teachers and colleagues. The trainee must demonstrate an awareness of how his/her own emotions, beliefs and attitudes may affect the care of patients or relationships with colleagues.

Team work: effective working relationships with peers and allied health workers

The clerk must demonstrate the ability to establish and maintain effective working relationships with colleagues and other health personnel. The clerk will contribute to the overall team effort by sharing the knowledge and expertise and demonstrate the capacity to accept and value the contributions of others. The clerk will demonstrate communications skills that facilitate the team effort.

 

Procedural Skills

Common ward procedures and/or OR assisting performed with care, judgement, & mastery

The clerk will demonstrate competence in the performance of the clinical procedures identified as basic in each clerkship.