PROCEDURES
FOR MANAGING CLERKS EXPERIENCING DIFFICULTIES
The following procedures
describe the process that should be followed for clerks experiencing academic
difficulties or difficulties in the clerkship process, where the latter may
or may not be related to academic issues. These procedures have been prepared
for and with the assistance of preceptors, course directors, and academic advisors.
- How are clerks
in difficulty identified?
- by self-assessment
- by clinical
supervisor
- by preceptors,
including other health care team members
- by examination
results (clerkship component scores, examination component scores, etc.)
- Who receives
the assessments of the clerks?
- clerks (all
formative and summative information)
- clerks'
academic advisors (all information, but only via clerks)
- the Dean's
office (summative information only)
- What is the
role of supervisors in identifying/helping clerks in difficulty?
If supervisors believe a clerk is experiencing academic problems, they should:
- first discuss
the situation with the clerk.
- recommend
to such clerks that they speak to their academic advisor, course director
or Associate Dean Student Affairs, depending on severity of problem.
- report (in
writing) the situation to the Associate Dean Student Affairs if the clerk
declines to seek help on their own volition (note: preceptors should report
difficulties to clinical supervisors and/or course directors and/or the
Associate Dean Student Affairs, not academic advisors).
- be rated
as 'requires improvement' or 'does not meet requirements' on the Assessment
of Clerk form, and specific narrative description of problems should be
provided.
- What is the
role of the academic advisor (see Academic Advisor Program Document)?
- review assessments
with clerk, and with the clerk's permission, liaise with the clerk's preceptors
or other members of the health care team
- recommend/help
arrange remedial work as needed, and with reference to the forward feeding
policy in item 6 below, encourage clerks to discuss their situation with
their subsequent clinical supervisors.
- What is failure
in a course?
- a score
of less than 60% in the composite course grade, or a score of less than
60% from any 'essential' component of the course grade or the composite
in-course grade.
- What is the
Dean's Office role during the term?
- to review
the Clinical Supervisor's Assessment of Clerk forms immediately at the
end of each clerkship, and to direct clerks judged as 'requires improvement'
or 'does not meet requirements' to meet with their academic advisor, course
director, or Associate Dean Student Affairs with a view to developing/implementing
a plan to help the clerk address identified deficiencies in particular
subject areas.
- to monitor
failing or clerks requiring improvement and notify the Associate Dean
Student Affairs if there is no improvement in a clerks progress.
- Associate
Dean, Student Affairs will advocate the forward feeding information on
clerks in difficulty to subsequent preceptors. However, the decision on
forward feeding should be made jointly by the Associate Dean and the clerk.
The goal of forward feeding is to help the clerk, and to alert clinical
supervisors to the difficulties being encountered by the clerk, so that
they may make an effective contribution to their resolution.
- What is the
Promotions Committee's role with clerks in academic difficulty?
- clerks who
fail one or two courses and whose overall average exceeds 60%, will be
given a supplemental examination in each course, on which they must achieve
a minimum of 65% to pass.
- clerks who
fail more than 2 courses fail the year will be required to repeat the
year or requested to withdraw from the program.
Clerks
Experiencing Professional Behaviour Difficulties in the Clerkship
Problems may arise
in clerkships relating to 'professional behaviour' or 'interpersonal dynamics'
among clerks or with a clerk and preceptor which may or may not be related to
academic problems, but which interfere with the learning process. The following
steps should be considered in addressing such problems, and these should be
pursued as quickly as possible. Which specific steps are followed will be contingent
on the severity and nature of the problem.
- Individual
Discussion with Clerk and Preceptor The preceptor who identifies the problem
should initiate a discussion of the situation as part of the feedback process,
with the goal of resolving the problem.
- Seek Outside
Assistance
If step #1 does not resolve the problem, the preceptor should bring the problem
to the attention of the clerkship clinical supervisor or course director.
All activities
relating to steps 1-2 should occur as quickly as possible (in the span of less
than 1 week).
- Refer Problem
to Associate Dean
If the problem persists, the clerkship director should recommend that the
clerk(s) meet with the Associate Dean Student Affairs to seek a solution to
the problem. If the clerk declines to meet with the Associate Dean, the clerkship
director should notify the Associate Dean in writing of the problem, and request
that a meeting be held with the clerk to resolve the problem.
- Forward Feeding
If the problem is in the process of being resolved through the above interventions
and if this process carries over to a new clinical supervisor and new clerkship,
the clerk should be encouraged by the Associate Dean to brief, or permit the
new clinical supervisor and new course director to be briefed on the problem,
and what is being done to resolve it. Preceptors and course directors in other
courses should also be briefed if the problem is believed to impact on their
role with the clerks. For example, since the clerks are in the same groups
across clerkship courses, it is likely that issues of group dynamics arising
in one setting will carry over to the other. The goal of forward feeding is
to help the clerk, and to alert clinical supervisors and course directors
to the difficulties being encountered by the clerk, so that they may make
an effective contribution to their resolution.
- Records
Letters, meeting summaries and other documentation pertaining to the problem
and the process of attempting its resolution should be obtained by the Associate
Dean and maintained in the Deans Office file of the clerk(s) in question.