APPEALS POLICY



Mark Appeal Process

The following outlines the policy and procedures for clerks to appeal a mark. Please note that in certain cases, if a clerk feels strongly that one of their marks is incorrect, the clerk may need to submit an appeal in writing. This written appeal must include the rationale supporting their request.

Appeal process for preceptor grade
When the mark is provided by a preceptor (including narrative assessments, written projects, ambulatory experiences, presentations, term papers, patient write-ups etc.):

Step 1: Clerk and preceptor meet and discuss discrepancy

    1. if a satisfactory agreement is reached, case closed
    2. if an agreement is not reached, go to Step 2

Step 2: Clerk brings appeal with written rationale to relevant course director who will facilitate a final resolution.

Appeal process for examinations
Note: The written portion of examinations as well as OSCEs involves a thorough review process by faculty content experts. The review process, which includes an analysis of the examination's item statistics, is aimed at eliminating errors in scoring, content and format.

Step 1: Clerk brings written rationale justifying marking change to the Clerkship Director who examines the rationale and item documentation, including statistical analysis information. The clerkship director, in conjunction with the appropriate content experts, makes every attempt to resolve the situation. If satisfactory agreement is not reached…

Step 2: The course director brings all relevant documents to the Associate Dean, Student Affairs, who will facilitate a final resolution.

Note: Failing satisfaction at these levels, there are University appeal procedures that may be followed.